All articles
Deep dive8 min read

An introductory offer refund can return the whole upfront payment, even after the subscriber ran up your server bill

A pay-up-front introductory offer puts several months of a subscription into one transaction, so one introductory offer refund can wipe out all of it. Here's how Apple and Google handle these refunds, what they cost you in compute and payouts, and how to answer with a prorated preference.

A phone on a wooden desk showing a discounted subscription checkout next to a printed receipt, the kind of upfront purchase an introductory offer refund can reverse

Key takeaways

  • Apple's pay-up-front introductory offer charges a new subscriber one discounted price for a set duration of 1, 2, 3 or 6 months, or 1 year, so a single refund can cover the entire offer period.
  • Google Play's single payment offer phase works the same way: one discounted charge covers a set duration of days, weeks or months before the base plan price starts.
  • Apple sends a CONSUMPTION_REQUEST for refund requests on auto-renewable subscriptions too. With the customer's consent, the developer has 12 hours to reply, and the refundPreference field accepts DECLINE, GRANT_FULL or GRANT_PRORATED.
  • For an auto-renewable subscription, Apple says not to send a consumptionPercentage with GRANT_PRORATED, because the App Store calculates the consumption itself.
  • A prorated App Store refund shows up as revocationType REFUND_PRORATED, with the refunded share in revocationPercentage in milliunits, so 40% arrives as 40000.
  • On Google Play, a developer can issue a partial refund from the Play Console website by percentage or pre-tax amount, and Google reduces the payout and the service fee by the same percentage.
  • Each person can redeem only one Apple introductory offer per subscription group, so an introductory offer refund usually ends the customer's cheapest way into your app.

Someone pays $14.99 up front for six months of your app, generates a few hundred images in the first two weeks, then asks Apple for their money back. If Apple grants it in full, every cent of that introductory offer refund comes out of your proceeds, and the model provider who billed you for those images still expects to be paid.

Pay-up-front introductory offers are a good acquisition tool. They also concentrate risk, because months of discounted subscription sit in one transaction. Below is how each store structures these offers, which fields tell you a refunded transaction was an introductory one, what the refund costs in real money, and the two places where you can ask for a partial refund instead of a full one.

How pay-up-front introductory offers are built on each store

Apple offers three kinds of introductory offer for auto-renewable subscriptions: free trial, pay as you go, and pay up front. In Apple's words, pay up front means new subscribers pay a one-time introductory price for a specific duration, such as $1.99 for 2 months. App Store Connect lets you set that duration to 1, 2, 3 or 6 months, or 1 year, whatever the length of the standard subscription. All subscriptions renew at the regular price when the introductory period is over.

Google Play builds the same idea out of offer phases. A free trial phase runs from 3 days to 3 years. A single payment phase is a discounted charge made once for a set duration. A discounted recurring payment phase repeats the discount for 1 to 52 billing periods. After the discounted phases end, the subscription renews at the base plan price.

Offer shapeApple nameGoogle Play nameHow many chargesWhat one refund can cover
No charge for a periodFree trialFree trial phaseNoneNothing to refund until the first paid renewal
One discounted charge for a long periodPay up frontSingle payment phaseOneThe whole offer period
A discounted charge every periodPay as you goDiscounted recurring payment phaseOne per periodOne period's discounted charge

Who can get the offer

Apple lets each person redeem one introductory offer per subscription group. Google's new customer acquisition eligibility covers users who have never had entitlement to this subscription or to any subscription in the app. Google also says that if it detects an attempt to get around eligibility rules, the user can still buy the base plan, just without the introductory price.

How to tell a refunded transaction was an introductory offer

Your refund handler should know what kind of purchase it's looking at before it revokes anything or reports a loss. Both stores put that on the transaction.

StoreFieldValue that means pay up front or single payment
AppleofferType1, an introductory offer
AppleofferDiscountTypePAY_UP_FRONT
AppleofferPeriodISO 8601 duration, for example P2M for two months
ApplerevocationTypeREFUND_FULL or REFUND_PRORATED after a refund
ApplerevocationPercentageShare refunded in milliunits, 100000 for a full refund
Google PlayofferPhaseintroductoryPrice while the discounted phase is active
Google PlayofferDetails.offerIdPresent only for discounted offers
Google PlaylatestSuccessfulOrderIdThe order that paid for the current period

Store the offer type, the offer period and the price paid on your own records at purchase time. When the refund arrives weeks later, you'll want to know it was a $14.99 six-month introductory payment and not a $9.99 monthly renewal, without calling an API under pressure.

What one introductory offer refund costs you in money

Here's an illustration with round numbers. Your regular plan is $9.99 a month. Your introductory offer is $14.99 up front for six months. A new subscriber buys it, and your proceeds after the store's commission are about $12.74 at a 15% rate.

That subscriber is busy in the first weeks. Say each image they generate costs you $0.04 in model API fees, and they make 300 of them: $12.00. You also pay for storage of their uploads and outputs, and for the support ticket they opened. Then they request a refund.

Line itemBefore the refundAfter a full refund
Proceeds from the store+$12.74$0.00
Model API fees for 300 images-$12.00-$12.00
Storage and bandwidthPaidPaid, not returned
Support timePaidPaid, not returned
Result+$0.74 before other costs-$12.00 before other costs

The point isn't the exact numbers. It's that the costs you pay for every API call, every gigabyte stored and every payout land in the first weeks, while the refund can reverse the entire payment. A discounted price leaves you less margin to absorb that.

A server rack with blue status lights behind a laptop showing a cost graph, illustrating the compute costs that remain after an introductory offer refund

Chargebacks make it worse on Google Play

A bank chargeback skips the refund request entirely. For Google Play orders placed after August 3, 2026, Google says the developer is responsible for the purchase price less Play's service fee, plus the chargeback fees charged by the financial institution. The bank fee comes on top of the loss in the table above.

How to ask Apple for a prorated refund instead of a full one

Apple decides App Store refunds, but it asks for your input first. When a customer requests a refund for any product type, auto-renewable subscriptions included, Apple sends a CONSUMPTION_REQUEST notification to your server. If the customer consented to sharing their data, you call Send Consumption Information within 12 hours. If they didn't consent, Apple says not to respond.

The refundPreference field takes three values: DECLINE, GRANT_FULL and GRANT_PRORATED. Apple says your preference is one of a variety of factors it uses. It isn't a veto.

The rule that trips people up

For an auto-renewable subscription, don't send a consumptionPercentage with GRANT_PRORATED. Apple says the system calculates the consumption automatically for auto-renewable subscriptions. Sending your own percentage for a subscription is the wrong request shape.

  • Set deliveryStatus to DELIVERED only if the subscription actually worked. If it didn't, consumptionPercentage has to be 0 or the request fails.
  • Set sampleContentProvided to true if the customer saw a free sample, a trial, or a description of what they'd get before buying.
  • Pick the preference from what the customer used. Heavy use of paid resources supports GRANT_PRORATED or DECLINE. A broken purchase supports GRANT_FULL.

If Apple grants a partial refund, the transaction comes back with revocationType REFUND_PRORATED and the refunded share in revocationPercentage. Book the loss from that number, not from the full price.

How to refund part of a Google Play introductory payment yourself

Google Play's self-service refund only runs for 48 hours after purchase. After that, Google tells the buyer to contact the developer. That's where you get a choice Apple doesn't give you: you can refund the order yourself, in full or in part.

  • Partial refunds are only available on the Play Console website, not the Play Console app.
  • You enter a percentage below 100% or a pre-tax amount below the order total.
  • Google reduces your payout and its service fee by the same percentage.
  • You can issue several partial refunds, as long as the total stays below the order total.
  • Refunds can't be reversed once issued.

A full refund on the most recent order also revokes the subscription and cancels future renewals. During a single payment phase, the introductory order is usually that most recent order, so a full refund ends access on the spot.

When the dispute is a chargeback

If a Google Play chargeback needs your input, Google sends a notification and you have 24 hours to call orders.reviewrefund with your refund preference and how the purchase was used. Usage records from the introductory period, such as API calls made and files generated, are exactly what that call is for.

How to size a pay-up-front offer around refund risk

  • Track refunds by offer type. If pay-up-front buyers refund more often than pay-as-you-go buyers, the single transaction is costing you.
  • Put usage limits on the introductory period that match its price, so the paid resources one subscriber can consume stay below what you collected.
  • Log usage per transaction from the first minute, so your CONSUMPTION_REQUEST and orders.reviewrefund replies have facts in them.
  • Compare the offer's net revenue after refunds, not its gross conversions. A cheap offer that converts well and refunds often can lose money.

Frequently asked questions

Can a customer get a refund on a pay-up-front introductory offer?
Yes. A pay-up-front introductory offer is an ordinary auto-renewable subscription transaction, so the customer can ask Apple for a refund, and Google Play buyers can request one within 48 hours or ask the developer after that. Because the offer is a single charge, a full refund returns the whole introductory payment.
Can I ask Apple to refund only part of an introductory offer?
You can ask, but Apple decides. Reply to the CONSUMPTION_REQUEST within 12 hours, with the customer's consent, and set refundPreference to GRANT_PRORATED. For auto-renewable subscriptions, leave out consumptionPercentage, because Apple calculates it. Apple treats your preference as one of several factors.
How do I know a refunded App Store transaction was an introductory offer?
Check the transaction fields. offerType 1 means an introductory offer, offerDiscountType PAY_UP_FRONT means one upfront payment, and offerPeriod gives the duration in ISO 8601 format, such as P2M. After a refund, revocationType shows REFUND_FULL or REFUND_PRORATED, and revocationPercentage shows the refunded share in milliunits.
Can I give a partial refund on a Google Play single payment offer?
Yes. On the Play Console website, you can refund a percentage below 100% or a pre-tax amount below the order total. Google reduces your payout and its service fee by the same percentage. Partial refunds aren't available in the Play Console app, and refunds can't be reversed.
Does a refund give the customer their introductory offer back?
Don't count on it either way. Apple allows one introductory offer per person per subscription group, and Google's new customer acquisition offers go to users who never had entitlement to a subscription in the app. Neither store's offer documentation says that a refund resets that eligibility.

Sources and further reading

RefundHalt

The refund autopilot for the App Store and Google Play

Keep reading

The next refund request is already on its way.

Set up RefundHalt in the time it takes to read another support email about a refund you didn't get to contest.