All articles
Policy watch8 min read

Brazil is now checking which games still sell loot boxes to kids, and loot box refunds are where the bill lands

Brazil's justice ministry asked the data protection authority to monitor six games that sell loot boxes without age checks. Here's what the law requires, what Apple and Google already demand, and how to price and handle loot box refunds when the box is already open.

A teenager on a sofa opening a glowing treasure chest in a mobile game, the paid pull that later turns into one of many loot box refunds

Key takeaways

  • On October 15, 2026, Brazil's Ministry of Justice and Public Security asked the national data protection authority, ANPD, to monitor games with loot boxes that haven't implemented age verification. Its Technical Note 55/2026 reviewed 15 titles and named six: NBA 2K26, WWE 2K26, Counter-Strike 2, Call of Duty, Genshin Impact and PUBG Mobile.
  • Article 20 of Brazil's Law 15.211/2025, the ECA Digital, bans loot boxes in games aimed at children and adolescents or likely to be accessed by them. The law took effect on March 17, 2026.
  • Under Article 23 of Brazil's Decree 12.880/2026, a game with loot boxes can verify age and block the feature for minors, offer a version without loot boxes, or switch the feature off by default for Brazilian users. The ministry says warnings, published odds or an 18+ rating alone don't meet the requirement.
  • Apple's App Review Guideline 3.1.1 requires apps that sell loot boxes or other randomized virtual items to disclose the odds of receiving each type of item before purchase. Google Play's Payments policy requires the odds to be disclosed in advance of, and in close and timely proximity to, the purchase.
  • When Apple sends a CONSUMPTION_REQUEST for a loot box purchase, the developer can report consumptionPercentage in milliunits for consumables. A bundle of 10 paid pulls with 4 opened is 40000, and an opened single pull is 100000.
  • Google Play records why a purchase was voided in the Voided Purchases API, with voidedReason values such as 1 Remorse, 4 Accidental_purchase and 7 Chargeback. Only a chargeback review through orders.reviewrefund asks the developer for evidence, with a 24-hour window.
  • For Google Play orders placed after August 3, 2026, a chargeback costs the developer the purchase price, less Play's service fee, plus the bank's chargeback fees.

Brazil's Ministry of Justice and Public Security has asked the country's data protection authority to watch six games that still sell loot boxes without checking how old the player is. The request went out on October 15, 2026, as a news post on the ministry's site and a technical note, not as a headline enforcement action. It names NBA 2K26, WWE 2K26, Counter-Strike 2, Call of Duty, Genshin Impact and PUBG Mobile. If you sell paid random rewards on iOS or Android, the bigger story for your books is loot box refunds. A box is opened the moment it's bought, so by the time a refund lands, the reward is already in the player's account.

What Brazil's ministry asked for, and why it matters outside Brazil

The ministry's National Secretariat of Digital Rights reviewed 15 titles and franchises with large audiences in Brazil. Nine had adapted. Six hadn't, and those six are the ones the ministry wants the authority, ANPD, to prioritize. The ministry is careful to say its survey is preliminary and can't, on its own, prove that any provider is or isn't compliant.

The rule behind it is Article 20 of Law 15.211/2025, known as the ECA Digital. It bans loot boxes in games aimed at children and adolescents or likely to be accessed by them. The law was signed on September 17, 2025, and took effect on March 17, 2026.

What counts as compliance under Decree 12.880/2026

Article 23 of Decree 12.880/2026 gives a game three ways to comply. It can verify users' ages and block the feature for minors. It can offer a version of the game without loot boxes. Or it can turn the feature off by default for Brazilian users. The ministry says the law doesn't necessarily ban loot boxes for adults, but access by minors has to be effectively blocked. A warning, published odds or an 18+ rating on its own doesn't do that.

The loot box rules you're already under on the App Store and Google Play

Outside Brazil, the store rules are about disclosure, not age. Both stores make you publish the odds. Neither one promises the player a refund because the draw was bad.

RuleWho it applies toWhat it requires
Apple App Review Guideline 3.1.1Every App Store app selling randomized virtual itemsDisclose the odds of receiving each type of item before purchase
Apple App Review Guideline 3.1.1Credits and in-game currencies bought through in-app purchaseThey may not expire
Google Play Payments policyApps and games selling randomized virtual itemsDisclose the odds in advance of, and in close and timely proximity to, the purchase
Brazil Law 15.211/2025, Article 20Games aimed at or likely to be accessed by children and adolescentsNo loot boxes
Brazil Decree 12.880/2026, Article 23Games with loot boxes available in BrazilAge checks that block minors, a version without loot boxes, or the feature off by default for Brazilian users

Do the stores refund a bad draw?

Not as a rule. A player who's unhappy with what came out of the box asks Apple or Google like any other customer. On Google Play, a customer may get a refund within 48 hours of purchase without you being asked. After that, Google sends them to you, and you decide under your own policy and applicable law. On the App Store, Apple decides every refund.

What loot box refunds cost you in money

A refund gives the player the price back. It doesn't give you back what that pull already set in motion. For a paid random reward, that's more than a server call.

Cost driverWhen you pay itRecovered after the refund?
Licensing royalties on gross receiptsAt your royalty statementOnly if your license nets out refunds
Revenue share or payouts to creators whose items are in the poolAt your payout runOnly if your terms allow a clawback
Items the player traded or sold to other playersAlready goneNo, unless you claw back from an innocent buyer
Soft currency and upgrade materials spent on the pulled itemAt consumptionOnly if you track and revoke them
Bank chargeback fees on Google Play orders after August 3, 2026At the chargebackNo

Here's a hypothetical. A player buys a $49.99 bundle of 50 pulls, opens all 50 and lands a licensed character. Your license pays the rights holder 10% of gross receipts every quarter, so $5.00 of that sale is owed before the refund arrives. If the license doesn't let you net out refunds, that $5.00 stays paid after the $49.99 goes back.

When a loot box purchase becomes a chargeback

A parent who finds a string of pull charges on a card statement may call the bank instead of the store. That's a chargeback, and it's final once the bank decides. For Google Play orders placed after August 3, 2026, you pay the purchase price, less Play's service fee, plus the bank's chargeback fees. A refund costs the sale. A chargeback costs the sale and a fee.

How to answer a loot box refund request on the App Store

Apple sends a CONSUMPTION_REQUEST when a customer asks for a refund on any product type. If the customer consented to share data, you have 12 hours to call Send Consumption Information. If they didn't, Apple rejects the call with an HTTP 400 error. Apple uses what you send as one factor among several, and the final refund percentage may differ from what you report.

Report consumption per pull, not per box

For consumables, consumptionPercentage is an integer in milliunits, so 100% is 100000. Apple's own example is a transaction with two consumables where one is used up, which is 50000. A multi-pull bundle works the same way. Count the pulls that were opened, not the rewards they produced.

Loot box situationdeliveryStatusconsumptionPercentage
Single paid pull, openedDELIVERED100000
10-pull bundle, 4 pulls openedDELIVERED40000
10-pull bundle, none opened yetDELIVERED0
Pull charged, reward never granted because your server was downUNDELIVERED_SERVER_OUTAGE0
Pull granted the wrong itemUNDELIVERED_WRONG_ITEM0

If deliveryStatus is anything other than DELIVERED, Apple requires consumptionPercentage to be 0, or the request fails. Your refundPreference can be GRANT_FULL, GRANT_PRORATED or DECLINE. A prorated preference needs a percentage above 0 and below 100000.

Use the reason Apple gives you

The notification carries consumptionRequestReason, the customer's own reason: UNINTENDED_PURCHASE, FULFILLMENT_ISSUE, UNSATISFIED_WITH_PURCHASE, LEGAL or OTHER. A bad draw usually shows up as UNSATISFIED_WITH_PURCHASE. Store the reason with the transaction. It tells you later whether your refunds come from regret, accidents or broken pulls.

How loot box refunds work on Google Play

Google doesn't ask you about most refunds. You find them afterward in the Voided Purchases API, with a voidedReason such as 1 Remorse, 4 Accidental_purchase or 7 Chargeback, and a voidedSource that says whether the user, the developer or Google voided it. Pull the API on a schedule, because a void you never see is a reward you never revoke.

The one exception is a chargeback. Google sends a PendingRefundReviewNotification, and you have 24 hours to call orders.reviewrefund with a refund preference and usage evidence. For a loot box, the evidence is the pull log: which pulls were opened and when.

Record what every paid pull produced

You can't unwind a loot box refund without knowing exactly what the refunded money bought. That's a data problem, and it's cheaper to solve before the refund than after.

A developer reviewing a ledger of item grants on a monitor, the per-pull record that makes loot box refunds possible to unwind
  • Write one row per pull: the store transaction ID, the pull number inside the bundle, the reward granted and the time.
  • If you sell premium currency instead of pulls, spend it first in, first out, and record which purchase funded each pull.
  • Keep the store's identifiers on every row: the Apple transactionId or the Google Play orderId and purchaseToken.
  • Mark traded or sold items, so a refund doesn't silently claw back an item from a player who never asked for one.

Will the game take the items back after a refund?

It should take back what the refunded money bought, and nothing else. Players ask this constantly, and some report keeping their currency after a refund. That's a revocation gap, not a policy. With a per-pull ledger, you remove the unspent pulls and the rewards they granted, and you leave the rest of the account alone.

Will my account be banned for requesting a refund?

That's the other question players ask. Banning a player for asking the store for a refund turns a single revoked item into a support fight and, often, a chargeback. Revoke the refunded rewards. Keep the account.

Frequently asked questions

Are loot boxes banned in Brazil?
Loot boxes are banned in Brazil in games aimed at children and adolescents or likely to be accessed by them, under Article 20 of Law 15.211/2025, which took effect on March 17, 2026. Brazil's Ministry of Justice says the law doesn't necessarily ban the feature for adults, but access by minors has to be effectively blocked.
Can players get a refund for a loot box on the App Store?
Yes, a player can ask Apple for a refund on a loot box purchase like any other in-app purchase, and Apple decides. If the customer consented, Apple sends the developer a CONSUMPTION_REQUEST, and the developer has 12 hours to send consumption information, including consumptionPercentage for the pulls opened.
Do Apple and Google require loot box odds to be published?
Yes. Apple's App Review Guideline 3.1.1 requires the odds of receiving each type of item to be disclosed before purchase. Google Play's Payments policy requires the odds to be disclosed in advance of, and in close and timely proximity to, the purchase.
What consumptionPercentage should I send for an opened loot box?
For a single paid pull that was opened, send 100000, which is 100% in milliunits. For a bundle, send the share of pulls opened, so 4 of 10 pulls is 40000. If the reward was never delivered, set deliveryStatus to the matching UNDELIVERED value and consumptionPercentage to 0.
Should I remove loot box items after a refund?
Yes, remove the unspent pulls and the rewards those refunded pulls granted, and leave the rest of the account alone. That only works if you record one row per pull with the store transaction ID, so you know exactly what the refunded money bought.

Sources and further reading

RefundHalt

The refund autopilot for the App Store and Google Play

Keep reading

The next refund request is already on its way.

Set up RefundHalt in the time it takes to read another support email about a refund you didn't get to contest.