All articles
Playbook8 min read

In-game trading lets a refunded purchase end up in someone else's inventory, so decide who pays before you ship it

When players can trade, gift or transfer what they bought, a store refund pulls the money back from the buyer while the value sits in another account. Here's how Apple and Google handle it, what it costs you, and how to set holds and clawback rules for in-game trading.

Two players on a city bench at dusk, each holding a phone open to a game inventory, the moment in-game trading moves a purchased item from one account to another

Key takeaways

  • In-game trading lets a player buy currency or items through the App Store or Google Play and move them to another account, so a later refund reverses the payment on one account while the value sits on another.
  • Apple's App Review Guideline 3.1.1 lets apps enable gifting of in-app purchase items, but says such gifts may only be refunded to the original purchaser and may not be exchanged.
  • Neither Apple nor Google refunds the recipient of a traded or gifted item. The store reverses the buyer's payment, and the developer decides whether to take anything back from the account that ended up holding it.
  • On Google Play, a customer may get a refund within 48 hours of purchase without the developer being asked, and unauthorized charges can be reported within 120 days of the transaction.
  • The Google Play Voided Purchases API only looks back 30 days, so a game that polls it less often than that can miss refunds on items that have already been traded away.
  • For Google Play orders placed after August 3, 2026, a chargeback costs the developer the purchase price, less Play's service fee, plus the bank's chargeback fees.
  • Roblox lengthened its pending sales hold in October 2020 from a flat three days to between three and seven days depending on the risk of fraud or abuse, which is the same tool any game with trading can use.

Trading turns a refund into a two-account problem. A player buys 10,000 gems through the App Store or Google Play, hands them to a second player, and then asks for their money back. The store reverses the payment on the first account. The gems are already sitting in the second one. If your game supports in-game trading, gifting or any kind of transfer between players, every refund now forces a choice the store won't make for you: take the value back from someone who may have done nothing wrong, or eat the loss.

Why in-game trading breaks the normal refund path

A normal refund is simple to unwind. One account paid, the same account got the goods, and you revoke what that account bought. Trading cuts that line. The account that paid and the account that holds the goods are no longer the same, and the store only knows about the first one.

That gap is an incentive. Someone can buy currency at full price, sell it to other players for cash at a discount on a third-party site, and then refund the original purchase. They keep the cash, the buyers keep the currency, and you keep nothing. Telegram's own terms for Stars show how seriously platforms take this. They restrict selling and transferring Stars held in a personal balance, and they say Telegram may temporarily withhold or permanently debit Stars in response to refunds of in-app purchases, with no compensation for the debited Stars.

What do Apple and Google say about gifted items?

Apple is the only store that addresses it directly. Guideline 3.1.1 lets apps enable gifting of items that are eligible for in-app purchase, and then adds that such gifts may only be refunded to the original purchaser and may not be exchanged. The money goes back to whoever paid. Nothing in the rule tells you what happens to the item the recipient is holding.

Google Play's refund pages don't mention trading at all. A refund or chargeback shows up against the order, and the order belongs to the buyer's Google account.

How long a refund can arrive after a trade

A trade happens in seconds. A refund can show up days or months later. These are the clocks that decide how long a traded item stays at risk.

EventWho decidesTime limitWhat the developer can do
Google Play self-service refundGoogleWithin 48 hours of purchaseNothing beforehand. It appears in the Voided Purchases API
Google Play refund after 48 hoursThe developerYour own policy and applicable lawDecide, and refund through the Play Console or API if you agree
Google Play unauthorized charge reportGoogleWithin 120 days of the transactionNothing beforehand. It appears as a void or a chargeback
Google Play chargeback reviewGoogle and the bank24 hours to answer the PendingRefundReviewNotificationCall orders.reviewrefund with a refund preference and usage evidence
App Store refund requestAppleNo window the developer controlsAnswer the CONSUMPTION_REQUEST within 12 hours, if the customer consented
Google Play Voided Purchases API lookbackNot a refund, a data limit30 daysPoll at least that often, or voids are gone from the list

Does a chargeback make it worse?

Yes, on Google Play. For orders placed after August 3, 2026, a chargeback costs you the purchase price, less Play's service fee, plus the bank's chargeback fees. A refund only takes the sale back. A chargeback takes the sale and adds a fee, and when the item has already been traded, the fee buys you nothing back.

What a refunded trade costs you in money

The refund itself is the visible part. The costs that hurt are the ones you already paid because the traded value was used before the refund landed.

Cost driverWhen you pay itRecovered by the store refund?
Creator or seller payouts for items bought with the traded currencyAt your payout runNo, only if your terms allow a clawback
Licensing royalties on gross receiptsAt your royalty statementOnly if your license nets out refunds
Server compute and third-party API calls the recipient usedWhen the recipient uses themNo
Your marketplace fee, if you charge one on tradesAlready collected, often already spent on payment processingNo
Bank chargeback fees on Google Play orders after August 3, 2026At the chargebackNo
Support time on the recipient's complaint after a clawbackAfter the clawbackNo

Here's a hypothetical. A player buys a $99.99 gem pack and spends the gems on five creator-made skins, then trades the skins to another player. Your creator program pays out 30% of the gem value, so about $30 has gone to creators before the refund. The store returns the $99.99 to the buyer and reverses your proceeds. If you can't recover the payout, you're down the $30 you paid creators on top of the sale you lost. If it was a Google Play chargeback after August 3, 2026, add the bank's fee.

Why is a trade hold cheaper than a clawback?

A hold delays the moment value leaves the buyer's account. If the refund arrives during the hold, you cancel the trade and nothing has moved. A clawback happens after the value has moved, so it lands on the recipient, who will often write to support or file a dispute of their own. Roblox moved its pending sales hold in October 2020 from three days to a range of three to seven days, depending on the risk of fraud or abuse. That's a hold sized by risk, not one fixed number for everyone.

How to set up in-game trading so refunds don't land on the wrong player

You can't stop refunds. You can make sure each one hits the right account, and that the value at risk is small while the refund windows are open.

Hold new value before it can be traded

  • Keep purchased currency and items untradable for at least the 48-hour Google Play self-service window, plus the time it takes your poll of the Voided Purchases API to run.
  • Lengthen the hold for new accounts, large purchases and accounts that have refunded before. Shorten it for long-standing accounts with clean history.
  • Let players use what they bought right away. Only the transfer to another account waits.

Tag every item with the purchase that funded it

  • Store the Apple transactionId, or the Google Play orderId and purchaseToken, on every unit of currency and every item it buys.
  • Spend currency first in, first out, so you always know which purchase paid for which item.
  • Carry the tag across trades. When a refund arrives, you need to find the item in whichever account holds it now.
A studio monitor showing a ledger of item transfers between player accounts, the record that makes in-game trading refunds traceable

Write the clawback rule before the first trade

Decide in your terms what happens to a traded item whose purchase is refunded. Wargaming's refund policy is a clear model. It says a refunded gift may be removed from the recipient's account, and that a chargeback on a gift may require blocking both the sender's and the recipient's accounts. Whatever you choose, put it where the recipient agrees to it before they trade.

Can I just ban the player who refunded?

You can lock the refunding account until the balance is repaid, and some publishers do. It doesn't fix the recipient's side, and it doesn't recover the payouts. Take back what the refunded money bought, wherever it sits, and put the account that refunded on a longer trade hold.

Answer the store when it asks

Two refund flows ask you for evidence, and trading gives you something specific to say in both. When Apple sends a CONSUMPTION_REQUEST and the customer has consented, you have 12 hours to send consumption information, and an item traded to another account was delivered and used. When Google sends a PendingRefundReviewNotification, you have 24 hours to call orders.reviewrefund, and Google records only your first call. A transfer log with timestamps is the usage evidence. Without it, you're arguing from memory.

Frequently asked questions

Can you refund a gifted in-app purchase?
Yes, a gifted in-app purchase can be refunded, and the money goes to the person who paid. Apple's App Review Guideline 3.1.1 says gifts may only be refunded to the original purchaser and may not be exchanged. Neither Apple nor Google refunds the recipient.
What happens to a traded item when the original purchase is refunded?
The store reverses the buyer's payment and leaves the item alone, so the developer decides. Some publishers remove the item from the recipient's account. Wargaming's refund policy, for example, says a refunded gift may be removed from the recipient's account.
How long should a trade hold be?
A trade hold should cover at least Google Play's 48-hour self-service refund window plus the time your poll of the Voided Purchases API takes, and longer for new or risky accounts. Roblox, for example, holds sales for three to seven days depending on the risk of fraud or abuse.
How far back does the Google Play Voided Purchases API go?
The Google Play Voided Purchases API goes back 30 days. Its startTime parameter can't be older than 30 days and defaults to the current time minus 30 days, so a game that polls less often than that can miss voided purchases.
Who pays when a traded item's purchase becomes a Google Play chargeback?
For Google Play orders placed after August 3, 2026, the developer pays the purchase price, less Play's service fee, plus the bank's chargeback fees. That cost stays even if the item was already traded to another player.

Sources and further reading

RefundHalt

The refund autopilot for the App Store and Google Play

Keep reading

The next refund request is already on its way.

Set up RefundHalt in the time it takes to read another support email about a refund you didn't get to contest.