All articles
Deep dive8 min read

Alternative app marketplace refunds in the EU are never Apple's job, so plan to run them yourself

Apple won't assist with refunds or payment disputes for iPhone apps sold through EU alternative app marketplaces, yet it takes a 5% commission and wants every refund reported. Here's who refunds what, what EU law adds, and what a refund costs you.

An iPhone on a cafe table in a European square beside a paper receipt and a euro coin, a picture of a purchase that falls under alternative app marketplace refunds instead of App Store refunds

Key takeaways

  • Apple says plainly that it won't assist with fraud, payment disputes or refunds for apps sold through an alternative app marketplace in the EU.
  • Apple's support page tells EU customers that apps downloaded outside the App Store follow their own policies for support and refunds, and that Apple In-App Purchase doesn't facilitate those purchases.
  • Apple's CONSUMPTION_REQUEST never fires for a purchase made in an app from an alternative app marketplace, because Apple didn't process the payment and has no refund to decide.
  • Under Apple's EU terms in effect since October 1, 2026, apps distributed through alternative marketplaces or the web pay a 5% Core Technology Commission on digital sales.
  • Developers selling digital goods in an alternatively distributed app must send Apple a monthly report within 15 days of month end, and Apple's report format says to report chargebacks as refunds.
  • EU consumers can cancel an online purchase within 14 days without a reason, unless they started downloading or streaming digital content after agreeing to lose that right.
  • A card chargeback on your own checkout follows the card network's rules: cardholders usually have 120 days to dispute, and you usually get 7 to 21 days to answer.

Sell an iPhone app through an alternative app marketplace in the EU and Apple steps out of the refund business entirely. Its developer page for marketplace operators says it in one sentence: Apple won't be able to assist with fraud, IP disputes, payment disputes, or refunds. Its consumer page tells buyers the same thing from the other side. Apps downloaded outside the App Store have their own policies for support and refunds.

That would be a clean split if Apple also stepped out of the money. It doesn't. Since October 1, 2026, Apple's revised EU terms charge a 5% Core Technology Commission on digital sales in apps distributed through alternative marketplaces or the web. Apple takes a share of the sale and none of the refund desk, and it still wants to hear about every refund you issue.

Who handles alternative app marketplace refunds

The refund lands on whoever took the customer's money. Apple's requirements for marketplace operators include "the ability to manage payment disputes and refunds", anti-fraud measures, and timely support. If the marketplace runs the checkout, its refund policy applies first, and its agreement with you decides whether a refund comes back out of your share. If your app runs its own checkout, you're the merchant and the refund is yours from start to finish.

Either way, Apple isn't in the chain. Its support page says the App Store and Apple In-App Purchase don't facilitate purchases in alternative app distribution, and it sends customers to the marketplace or the app developer for help.

QuestionApp Store app with Apple In-App PurchaseApp from an EU alternative app marketplace
Who takes the paymentAppleThe marketplace or your own checkout
Who decides a refundAppleThe marketplace or you
Does Apple send a CONSUMPTION_REQUESTYes, with a 12-hour window to answerNo
Where a chargeback goesApple's payment sideThe payment processor that charged the card
Family Sharing and Ask to BuySupportedNot supported, per Apple
Apple's commissionApp Store rates5% Core Technology Commission
Refund reporting to AppleNone, Apple already knowsMonthly report within 15 days of month end

Does Apple's consumption request still apply?

No. Only two refund flows anywhere ask the developer for evidence before the store decides. Apple sends a CONSUMPTION_REQUEST and gives you 12 hours to answer through Send Consumption Information. Google Play opens a chargeback review you answer through orders.reviewrefund within 24 hours. Both exist because the store charged the card. A purchase in a marketplace app never touched Apple's payment system, so there's no store review to win and no store review to lose.

What do I owe customers under EU law?

More than you might expect. The EU's consumer rules let a buyer cancel an online contract within 14 days without giving a reason. For services, that clock starts the day the contract is agreed. There is an exception for online digital content, such as a song or a film, once the customer started downloading or streaming it after agreeing to lose the right. If you want that exception, the agreement has to happen before the content is delivered, inside your purchase flow. A line buried in your terms isn't the same thing.

What the 5% commission means for refunds

Apple's newsroom announcement of August 18, 2026 set the new EU structure: 26% or 15% for App Store apps using Apple In-App Purchase, lower rates for alternative payments and link-outs, and a 5% Core Technology Commission for apps distributed through alternative marketplaces or the web. The same announcement replaced the old per-install Core Technology Fee.

The commission rides on a reporting duty. Apple's App Store Connect help says that any time you sell digital goods and services in an alternatively distributed app, you must submit a monthly report within 15 days after the end of the calendar month. The report covers all tokens, including refunds, corrections, renewals, one-time purchases and attempts that never became a purchase.

  • Refunds go in as a RefundLineItem that points at the original purchase line through its referenceLineItemId.
  • Partial refunds are allowed. Apple's own example report shows a partial refund of a one-time charge.
  • Chargebacks are reported as refunds too. Apple's documentation says it in four words: report chargebacks as a refund.
  • Each line carries a net amount that, in Apple's words, accounts for all refunds and restatements.
  • On OS versions earlier than 26.4 in the EU, Apple says these reports have to be completed manually.
A desk with a laptop showing a payments dashboard next to printed monthly statements, a red pen and a calculator, a picture of the monthly refund reporting that comes with alternative app marketplace sales

What a refund on a marketplace sale costs you in money

Take a €10 credit pack sold through your own checkout in a marketplace app. Apple's commission on the sale is 5%, or €0.50. Your payment processor takes its fee on top, and most processors don't hand that fee back on a refund. Stripe, for one, charges a dispute fee when a cardholder files a dispute and, outside Mexico, never returns it, even if you win.

OutcomeMoney that leavesNotes
Customer keeps the purchase€0.50 commission plus your processor feeReported to Apple as a one-time charge
You refund it in full€10.00 to the customer, and the processor fee stays spentReport it to Apple as a RefundLineItem
Customer disputes it with their bank€10.00, held during the dispute and gone if you lose, plus a dispute fee you don't get backReport it to Apple as a refund. Your processor's dispute process is the only one
Same purchase through Apple In-App Purchase on the App StoreApple decides the refund and takes it from your proceedsYou get a CONSUMPTION_REQUEST and 12 hours to answer

The fees are the small part. If the credits were spent before the refund, the costs behind them were already paid: GPU time for every image generated, paid model or data API calls behind every answer, storage for every file exported, a payout to the creator whose content was unlocked. A refund returns €10 to the customer. It returns none of those bills to you.

Can I fight a chargeback on my own checkout?

Yes, and that's the one thing you gain. On the App Store, a bank dispute is Apple's problem and you never see the evidence. On your own processor, you can answer it. Stripe's documentation says cardholders usually have 120 days from the payment to dispute, you usually get 7 to 21 days to submit evidence, and the bank's decision can take 60 to 75 days after that. Usage records, delivery logs and the customer's own account history are your evidence, so keep them.

What to set up before you ship to a marketplace

  • Put a refund request path inside the app and on your website. A customer who can't find one goes to their bank instead.
  • Show the withdrawal-right waiver for digital content before delivery, with an explicit tick or button, if you plan to rely on it.
  • Store Apple's external purchase token and line item ID next to your processor's charge ID, so a refund can be reported in one lookup.
  • Report refunds from the same code path that issues them, including refunds someone issues by hand in the processor's dashboard.
  • Report every chargeback as a refund in the next monthly report, whether you contest it or not.
  • Read your marketplace agreement for its own refund policy and how it recovers refunds from your share.

RefundHalt answers every CONSUMPTION_REQUEST and Google Play chargeback review inside its window with your real usage data, for the sales that still run through Apple and Google. For the sales you move to an alternative marketplace, the defense is a clear refund path, a fast answer to every request, and a clean monthly report to Apple.

Frequently asked questions

Does Apple handle refunds for apps from alternative app marketplaces in the EU?
No. Apple's developer page says it won't be able to assist with fraud, IP disputes, payment disputes or refunds for alternative app marketplaces. Its consumer page tells buyers to contact the marketplace or the app developer, whose own refund policies apply.
Will I get a CONSUMPTION_REQUEST for a purchase in a marketplace app?
No. Apple only sends a CONSUMPTION_REQUEST for purchases it processed through Apple In-App Purchase. Apple says In-App Purchase doesn't facilitate purchases in alternatively distributed apps, so there's no Apple refund review to answer.
Do I have to report refunds to Apple for alternatively distributed apps?
Yes. Apple requires a monthly report within 15 days after the end of each calendar month for digital sales in alternatively distributed apps, and it must include refunds and corrections. Refunds go in as a RefundLineItem, and Apple says to report chargebacks as refunds.
What commission does Apple charge on alternative app marketplace sales?
5%. Apple's EU terms, announced on August 18, 2026 and in effect since October 1, 2026, apply a 5% Core Technology Commission to digital sales in apps distributed through alternative marketplaces or the web.
Can EU customers cancel an in-app purchase within 14 days?
Often, yes. EU consumer rules give buyers 14 days to cancel an online contract without a reason. The right doesn't apply to online digital content the customer started downloading or streaming after agreeing to lose it, so that agreement has to come before delivery.

Sources and further reading

RefundHalt

The refund autopilot for the App Store and Google Play

Keep reading

The next refund request is already on its way.

Set up RefundHalt in the time it takes to read another support email about a refund you didn't get to contest.